top of page

Garment Evaluation Rubric

Focus: Intersectional Identity

For senior designers, Critique and Evaluation is an in-depth review of each collection by the judges. They meticulously examine every aspect of the garments, with a focus on craftsmanship—from the stitching to fabric selection. This thorough evaluation ensures each piece is not only visually captivating but also expertly constructed.

​

Creativity is a key factor; judges seek out innovative and original designs, particularly those that offer a unique interpretation of the theme, 'Intersectional Identity'. Additionally, fit plays a critical role. Judges evaluate how well the garment fits the body, emphasizing both aesthetic appeal and practical wearability.

​

Marketability is another important consideration. Judges assess the design’s potential to resonate with current fashion trends while also standing out in the marketplace. They look at the overall impact of the collection, analyzing how each piece contributes to a cohesive, compelling runway presentation.

​

Each element of the design is rated on a 1-10 scale, allowing for a detailed and fair assessment. However, the evaluation goes beyond numbers—it’s about appreciating the vision, creativity, and hard work that each senior designer puts into their collection.

Runway Rubric

Rating Scale:

  • Each criterion is rated on a scale from 1 to 10.

  • 1: Lowest | 10: Highest

  • Total possible score: 60 (10 points for each of the 6 categories).

        

1. Construction and Quality​

  • Precision: Attention to detail in stitching and finishing.

  • Durability: Use of materials and techniques for longevity.

  • Complexity: Technical difficulty in construction.

 

Scale: 1 (Low) - 10 (High)

1-3: Poor construction, visible flaws, weak seams, and low durability.

4-6: Basic construction, some minor flaws, adequate durability.

7-10: Superior construction, impeccable finishing, high durability, and attention to detail.

 

2. Fabric and Material Selection​

  • Appropriateness: Suitability for the design and function.

  • Texture and Color: The use of texture and color enhances the design.

  • Innovation: Use of unconventional or innovative materials.

 

Scale: 1 (Low) - 10 (High)

1-3: Inappropriate fabric, poor color or texture choice.

4-6: Adequate fabric quality, color, texture, and innovation.

7-10: High-quality fabric, excellent color and texture choice, innovative material use.

        

3. Design Creativity and Originality​

  • Innovation: Novelty and departure from conventional styles.

  • Artistic Expression: Reflecting artistic and aesthetic qualities.

  • Theme Interpretation: Incorporation of the 'True Delusion' theme.

 

Scale: 1 (Low) - 10 (High)

1-3: Lacks originality, derivative design, minimal artistic expression.

4-6: Some creative elements, moderate originality, and artistic expression.

7-10: Highly creative and original, strong artistic and aesthetic qualities, unique theme interpretation.

 

4. Fit and Functionality​

  • Comfort: Consideration of the wearer's comfort and practicality.

  • Fit: Tailoring and sizing accuracy.

  • Functionality: Practical aspects like pockets, closures, etc.

 

Scale: 1 (Low) - 10 (High)

1-3: Poor fit, uncomfortable, lacking in practical features.

4-6: Reasonable fit, moderate comfort, some practical features.

7-10: Excellent fit, highly comfortable, functional with well-considered features.

 

5. Market Appropriateness and Appeal​

  • Target Market Suitability: Alignment with target market needs.

  • Commercial Viability: Potential for market success.

  • Trend Sensitivity: Awareness of current fashion trends.

 

Scale: 1 (Low) - 10 (High)

1-3: Does not appeal to the target market.

4-6: Somewhat appealing to the target market.

7-10: Highly appealing to the target market.

​

6. Overall Aesthetic and Style

  • Visual Impact: Immediate visual appeal and impact.

  • Cohesiveness: Harmony of all design elements.

  • Styling: Presentation of the look.

 

Scale: 1 (Low) - 10 (High)

1-3: Poor visual impact, lacks cohesiveness.

4-6: Adequate visual appeal, some cohesiveness.

7-10: Strong visual impact, highly cohesive design, and presentation.

 

bottom of page